Bullseye-L Forum
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

+9
Wobbley
DA/SA
Toz35m
Rodger Barthlow
Founder
Merick
chiz1180
Dcforman
john bickar
13 posters

Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by john bickar 9/20/2024, 7:36 pm

Previous thread got shut down due to misbehavior, apparently. There was some good info there, which was lost, unfortunately.

Thoughts, or more importantly, data?
john bickar
john bickar

Posts : 2250
Join date : 2011-07-09
Age : 100
Location : Menlo Park, CA

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by Dcforman 9/20/2024, 7:53 pm

Damn, what did I miss?!?

Dave

Dcforman

Posts : 919
Join date : 2017-11-18
Age : 43
Location : Ohio

john bickar likes this post

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by chiz1180 9/20/2024, 7:56 pm

Dcforman wrote:Damn, what did I miss?!?

Dave
TLDR: case length may or may not matter, incomplete data/different testing methods. Basically.
chiz1180
chiz1180

Posts : 1456
Join date : 2019-05-29
Location : Ohio

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by Merick 9/20/2024, 8:10 pm

I'd guess there may be a self compensating effect that we don't understand or can't measure. A long case shoots well for one reason, a short case for another, and the tradeoff happens between the two without our knoledge.

Say for example initial internal case pressure was the important factor, a long case may meet whater psi by having more neck tension, and a short case my get close to the same psi by having less internal volume.  

Or another hypothetical example with two factors; a lightly crimped bullet in good condition over a poorly ignited charge from the low crimp may well be indistinguishable on target from a lightly mangled hard crimped bullet over a charge that ignited well.

Or it just might not make a difference.


Last edited by Merick on 9/20/2024, 8:26 pm; edited 2 times in total

Merick

Posts : 446
Join date : 2015-08-13
Location : Kansas

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by Founder 9/20/2024, 8:18 pm

There is some data in this forum from Jerry Keefer on this topic. 

Around the same time as he was sharing his data, I had a match where I was 20 rounds short on 45 ammo s o I took 20 rounds of ammo with split cases, some of which was so worn that you could hardly see the headstamp and used it in slow fire. You all know I'm no John Shue, but I still pounded a 96...and that 8 (and the rest) went right on call. The other 10 were a 94. No flyers.
.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Fb_img10

There is a hell of a lot more to gain in training, mental management, dry firing, and conditioning.

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Tenor_10
Founder
Founder
Moderator

Posts : 784
Join date : 2011-06-09
Age : 51
Location : Brooklyn, WI.

https://www.bullseyeforum.net

8eightring, bruce martindale, Fotomaniac, Rush223, 10sandxs, DA/SA, djperry2 and TonyH like this post

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by Rodger Barthlow 9/23/2024, 10:36 am

Founder wrote:There is some data in this forum from Jerry Keefer on this topic. 

Around the same time as he was sharing his data, I had a match where I was 20 rounds short on 45 ammo s o I took 20 rounds of ammo with split cases, some of which was so worn that you could hardly see the headstamp and used it in slow fire. You all know I'm no John Shue, but I still pounded a 96...and that 8 (and the rest) went right on call. The other 10 were a 94. No flyers.
.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Fb_img10

There is a hell of a lot more to gain in training, mental management, dry firing, and conditioning.

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Tenor_10
I have missed culling split cases and found no difference when shooting. To me overall bullet length is more important than brass case length. 
Shoving an over length loaded cartridge into a chamber jamming the bullet into the lands and grooves of the barrel changes breach pressure and will cause a flier quicker than anything else I can think of. 
You can feel the difference when it is discharged.
Rodger Barthlow
Rodger Barthlow

Posts : 388
Join date : 2013-08-10

bruce martindale likes this post

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by john bickar 9/23/2024, 11:30 am

Founder wrote:John Shue

Q: How many times do you have to win Camp Perry to get your name spelled correctly?

A: Apparently at least one more time than Jon Shue has.

Laughing
john bickar
john bickar

Posts : 2250
Join date : 2011-07-09
Age : 100
Location : Menlo Park, CA

Founder and Hawkja like this post

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by Toz35m 9/23/2024, 11:46 am

If we want people to test and post results we should more appreciative for the time and money they put into getting the results.

Something like this happens and makes me less willing to share what I find.  Sometimes it is better to not hit SEND.

Not everyone understands the scientific method but we can help guide them.

Maybe next time we suggest a similar test instead of telling them they did it wrong. If they are willing to spend the time and money on primers and bullets they might do the test and post the results for us all to see. Another option is if someone is willing to provide something to test to someone will and maybe post the results.
Toz35m
Toz35m

Posts : 261
Join date : 2012-10-17
Location : PDX

DA/SA likes this post

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by DA/SA 9/23/2024, 12:03 pm

From what I remember, Chase's test was exactly what the topic title said it was. It demonstrated the effects on case length, and case length only, by using the same headspace on each round from a barrel tester. 

I don't know that his intended test was to determine "1911 case length and impacts on accuracy", which some interpreted it to be a test of.

Just a thought...
DA/SA
DA/SA

Posts : 1446
Join date : 2017-10-09
Age : 68
Location : Southeast Florida

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by Wobbley 9/23/2024, 12:48 pm

I’m not 100% sure exactly what the headspace was set to during the test.  That data was destroyed by the OP prior to me deleting the thread.

I did propose a test method of 2 series of 7 ten shot groups to be fired one series with cases at long length and one series at minimum case length.  The headspace would have been set for the longer cases.

I’m not fully convinced that headspace in a pistol truly affects accuracy.  I know in rifle that benchresters no longer neck size only.  And an auto loading pistol is not like a rifle at all.  But a series of tests might put that notion to bed.
Wobbley
Wobbley
Admin

Posts : 4737
Join date : 2015-02-12

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by S148 9/23/2024, 2:47 pm

Wobbley wrote:I’m not fully convinced that headspace in a pistol truly affects accuracy.

If history is right, the 38 Super is an example of the importance of headspace. The 'old' guns were chambered to headspace on the semi-rim, and was reported to be the cause of poor accuracy. Accuracy improved when the barrel was chambered to headspace on the case mouth.

The original report is in the 1961 American Rifleman. Rollins, John and Shockley, Richard 1961. Accurizing The Colt Super .38. American Rifleman, 109 (6), 40-41.

S148

Posts : 313
Join date : 2017-07-04

PhotoEscape likes this post

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by Rodger Barthlow 9/24/2024, 11:19 am

Looks like this is going down a rabbit hole comparing a straight wall case to a bottle neck rifle cartridge.
It has been proven that Rim thickness in pistol cartridge case manufacture is one of the main causes for inaccuracy for head spacing off the rim instead of the case mouth. The reasoning for the 38 Super and .38Spl head spacing off the case mouth in 1911 semi auto pistols.
Rodger Barthlow
Rodger Barthlow

Posts : 388
Join date : 2013-08-10

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by SteveT 9/24/2024, 8:00 pm

I've always assumed case length was one of the many things in bullseye that if you think it will affect accuracy, then it does. If you don't think it matters, it probably won't.
SteveT
SteveT

Posts : 1095
Join date : 2011-06-10
Location : Illinois

https://sites.google.com/site/sdturner/shooting

Sa-tevp and DA/SA like this post

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by john bickar 9/24/2024, 8:51 pm

Dcforman wrote:Damn, what did I miss?!?

Dave

Apparently someone misbehaved, David.

You've shot shoulder-to-shoulder with me at various venues. Have you ever known me to misbehave?

Stop. Don't answer that.
john bickar
john bickar

Posts : 2250
Join date : 2011-07-09
Age : 100
Location : Menlo Park, CA

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by SmokinNJokin 9/24/2024, 9:19 pm

Another variable to consider… generally, all things being equal longer cases will be newer brass with less firings, and shorter cases will have more firings and therefore more resizing and be work-hardened (unless you are annealing your pistol brass… im sure theres at least 1 person on this forum that has done it).

My educated guess, based on the excellent accuracy observed with both long and short brass, is that softer brass shoots better, not necessarily longer. Brass minimally resized (i expand and resize with .45 colt dies, barely squeezes the brass either way with no belling of the mouth) gets less work hardened and lasts far longer… does that equate to more consistent groups? Conversely, if you bust your brass down violently with an undersized die then blunderbuss out your case mouth repeatedly… you get where im going with this.

New starline is usually .893, and most of mine has shrunk into the .880s, i would be curious to pull bullets from unfired rounds of the usual suspects headstamps and see what other new brass measures.


Last edited by SmokinNJokin on 9/24/2024, 9:21 pm; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : fat fangers)

SmokinNJokin

Posts : 850
Join date : 2015-07-27
Location : Wisconsin Rapids

fc60 and DK like this post

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by bruce martindale 9/25/2024, 8:14 am

Fired brass expands radially and hence becomes shorter. I have heard that new brass was a key to the best longline ammo but failed to understand all the reasons why. Perhaps New star brass is best because a) it’s longer,  b) smaller diameter so it can settle up correctly in the chamber , and c) hasn’t workhardened

bruce martindale

Posts : 1713
Join date : 2011-07-29
Location : Upstate NY

https://www.bullseyeforum.net/t20747-feeling-center-a-10-bullsey

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by Merick 9/25/2024, 8:47 am

bruce martindale wrote:Fired brass expands radially and hence becomes shorter. I have heard that new brass was a key to the best longline ammo but failed to understand all the reasons why. Perhaps New star brass is best because a) it’s longer,  b) smaller diameter so it can settle up correctly in the chamber , and c) hasn’t workhardened
I had some new starline brass and when I weight sorted it, it was two distinct lots and one was more than a sd lighter than my motley range brass collection.

Merick

Posts : 446
Join date : 2015-08-13
Location : Kansas

Back to top Go down

.45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy Empty Re: .45ACP case length and impacts on accuracy

Post by Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum